Ok everyone. The time has finally come to properly re-design the community experience of Slant. Here is the things in the scope of this project:
Editing/adding
Voting
Commenting
History
Activity
Moderation
Notifications/re-engagement
Profiles
Karma
Flagging
Data syncing
External API data
Community structure (categories)
Account creation & management
Content Quality tracker “Needs improvement”
Things out of scope:
Question Navigation
Information ontology
Search
Information display
Information consumption
Ranking/ordering
Feed design
Lets use this thread to compile just the complaints about the current system (there will be a separate post for ideas). Have at it! Feel free to just paste the URL to existing meta posts.
High-level priority issues
-
Everything requires lots of clicking and waiting for things to load
-
Amount of views creates cognitive complexity
-
Contributing is difficult
-
Engaging is difficult
General
-
No way to move/merge options
-
No way to contribute anonymously
-
Astroturfing is an issue
-
Open-endedness of contributing is part of what’s making the process daunting.
-
No public centralized place to look at all content issues
-
High-traffic situations create server issues
Summary/Questions
Communication/engaging
Tags
- No way to add custom tags
Activity & Notifications
- Some form of notification to inform of deprecated questions, duplicates to be deleted, potentially astroturfed content, locked questions, etc
Profiles & Following
-
Aren’t that useful.
-
No way to show them off.
Editor
-
Editor is daunting and unclear
-
Editing lacks some sort of user guidance.
-
No way to add pros and cons at the same time
-
Requires clicking and waiting to load each time an edit has to be made
-
Don’t think slide-out will work on mobile. Plus, it’s less intuitive than in-line.
Content guidelines & policies
- Need content guidelines and policies
Discovery